20120620 - Simulation: nutritional balance of breakfast meals - 2012

[Data] [<Normal page] [PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2012). Simulation: nutritional balance of breakfast meals. Journal of Knowledge Advancement & Integration (ISSN 1177-4576), 2012, pages 152-154.]

Breakfast meals' BNI (simulation)

This article presents the results of a simulation on the nutritional balance of breakfast meals, carried out as part of a research on the nutritional composition of breakfast in New Zealand. A breakfast meal is understood as a combination of breakfast cereals with water6, milk, non-dairy milk or yogurt.

Illustration 1 collates the Balanced Nutrition Index™ (BNI™) for each simulated meal. Although all meals balanced out at least one ingredient, only 53% of the meals improved the nutritional balance of both ingredients. Non-dairy milks produced more balanced meals, overall, followed by natural yogurt and non-flavored dairy milk. Among yogurts and milk, low-fat options (but not fat-free ones) were the most balanced of all. Meanwhile, flavored milks and yogurts might have become more balanced as part of a meal but were poorer options than unflavored ones. Regardless of above, an oat meal made with water (eg, porridge) was the most balanced breakfast meal in the simulation, and oats resulted in more balanced meals when using any milk, non-dairy milk or yogurt than any other breakfast cereals.

Illustration 1: BNI of breakfast meals (simulation)
Food product Oat Muesli Wheat Corn Rice Bran
Serving 37g 46g 32g 29g 30g 32g
BNI 8.70 23.82 31.11 78.35 80.03 121.81
Standard oatmilk 250ml 16.91 9.82 12.15 13.60 22.26 23.61 15.85
Low-fat soymilk 250ml 26.77 10.10 22.45 17.11 25.51 29.77 33.77
Standard ricemilk 250ml 38.13 19.80 29.21 30.13 43.26 44.75 36.57
Standard soymilk 250ml 48.17 14.04 20.71 12.96 19.99 23.56 36.86
Fat-free soymilk 250ml 52.32 18.30 25.06 30.88 38.72 38.97 45.81
Low-fat natural yogurt 150g 54.72 18.51 30.42 26.64 36.87 41.22 51.85
Low-fat flavored soymilk 250ml 64.29 34.20 42.11 41.61 50.13 53.34 56.39
Standard natural yogurt 150g 67.50 25.72 33.44 32.06 42.23 45.76 51.93
Creamy natural yogurt 150g 77.49 37.10 42.10 43.16 51.84 55.36 59.64
Standard cow milk 250ml 88.42 43.23 47.94 49.68 57.29 60.09 65.21
Fat-free flavored yogurt 150g 90.26 27.57 38.50 36.82 49.56 53.84 68.05
Low-fat flavored yogurt 150g 91.56 44.83 51.79 53.70 64.10 67.29 74.12
Semi-skimmed cow milk 250ml 92.68 31.93 40.57 39.90 49.38 52.97 64.95
Standard flavored soy yogurt 150g 92.90 49.98 54.81 58.28 67.49 71.06 74.53
Creamy flavored yogurt 150g 94.19 46.09 50.10 52.75 61.41 64.88 71.11
Standard flavored yogurt 150g 95.20 46.41 50.40 53.12 61.81 65.28 71.71
Semi-skimmed flavored cow milk 250ml 101.11 51.57 56.95 59.36 66.94 69.73 77.20
Standard flavored cow milk 250ml 104.13 56.73 59.60 63.30 69.96 72.78 77.99
Skimmed cow milk 250ml 122.85 40.70 47.02 51.12 58.37 62.14 84.88
Fat-free natural yogurt 150g 125.80 33.50 43.65 44.29 56.80 61.02 85.78
(White cells show improved BNIs for one ingredient; grey cells show improved BNIs for both ingredients )

Methods

Research approach

Exploratory study.

Data

The initial research sample included average nutrition data for 6 categories of breakfast cereals (see Perezgonzalez, 20125) and 20 types of non-dairy milks, dairy milks and yogurts (see Perezgonzalez, 2011b2, 2011c3, 2011d4).

Materials & analysis

Relevant data were used to run a simulation combining ingredients to make a meal according to the following parameters:

  • a serving of 250ml of milk or non-dairy milk, or a serving of 150g of yogurt, as first ingredient
  • a serving of cereals amounting to approximately 1 cup as second ingredient.

The resulting meal was then assessed using the Balanced Nutrition Index™ (BNI™) technology (see Perezgonzalez, 2011a1). SPSS-v18 was used for the computation of variables, including BNI and international indexes.

Generalization potential

This simulation was based on average nutrition data per ingredient, taken from related research. It provides a reasonable assessment of nutritional balance as per the serving sizes used. Thus, the results of this study may be taken as representing the average nutritional balance of real breakfast meals.
As breakfast cereals and milks and yogurts were made in NZ or imported from Australia, the results of this study may be generalizable to the following populations (in order of decreasing generalization power):

  • Australia.
  • Internationally, if one assumes breakfast cereals, milks and yogurts to be of approximately similar nutritional composition anywhere.
References
1. PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2011a). Balanced Nutrition Index™ (BNI™). Journal of Knowledge Advancement & Integration (ISSN 1177-4576), 2011, pages 20-21. Also retrievable from Wiki of Science.
2. PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2011b). Milking veggies. The Balanced Nutrition Index (ISSN 1177-8849), 2011, issue 5.
3. PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2011c). White gold. The Balanced Nutrition Index (ISSN 1177-8849), 2011, issue 6.
4. PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2011d). Yogurts galore. The Balanced Nutrition Index (ISSN 1177-8849), 2012, issue 1.
5. PEREZGONZALEZ Jose D (2012). Breakfast cereals. The Balanced Nutrition Index (ISSN 1177-8849), 2012, issue 3.
+++ Notes +++
6. The BNI of dry cereals can also be taken as the BNI of the corresponding breakfast meal when using plain water as the second ingredient

Want to know more?

BNI™ database
The database offers individual nutrition analyses for foods, including the ingredients referred to in above article.
Wiki of Science - Nutritional balance of breakfast cereals
This Wiki of Science page collates information about breakfast cereals, and provides useful links to the appropiate files.
Wiki of Science - Nutritional balance of milk and yogurt types
This Wiki of Science page collates information about milk, non-dairy milk and yogurt, and provides useful links to the appropiate files.

Author

Jose D PEREZGONZALEZ (2012). Massey University, Turitea Campus, Private Bag 11-222, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand. (JDPerezgonzalezJDPerezgonzalez).


BlinkListblogmarksdel.icio.usdiggFarkfeedmelinksFurlLinkaGoGoNewsVineNetvouzRedditYahooMyWebFacebook

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License